Peconic Bay Diner in Riverhead

Fast and very good service, everyone at the dinner was very attentive.

Terrible service. Never asked if you want more coffee, never filled glass of soda, cake was horrible. Forgot the gravy, forgot the mayo. Will never go back. And it was 3/4 empty. Very disappointed. Moriches diner is cheaper n way better

Food was dried out and over cooked. Have 2 stars bc the staff was Very noce

I came here for breakfast. The food was extremely delicious and the staff were so accommodating. They kept us properly supplied with a steady amount of coffee and food. In fact, the recommendation from our waitress was so helpful and appreciated. I'd certainly recommend eating the NY Sirloin Steak with eggs.

Food was bland. Pancakes were cold and soggy and tasted bland. Gave lunch a shot one day and the burger was overcooked and dry. Staff is pleasant but doesn't make up for the food quality.

Old school diner...food was good, service was good.

Love this diner. Annie is the best waitress in Riverhead

Food was blah, Mexican omlette looked and tasted more like mandala, no spice. The look was even less appetizing. The French toast was thick and couldn't taste any cinnamon. The bacon was burnt and overcooked, they replaced it with limp bacon. Think they cook it earlier then heat it up.

I went for breakfast with a party of four. It's a typically diner, which is a good thing to me. We all enjoy our meal, and the service was good.

Love it here! Friendlt service and very clean!

Large portions, good food and service

Been going here for many years and the food is always consistently good. The service is fast and friendly. Always recommended.

A classic diner with a great selection. Good service.

We had great service and a reasonably priced dinner special that was delicious. We left there stuffed. What more can you ask for?

Great French toast!!! Challa bread style.

The person in charge of charging should have a better attitude 👎👎👎👎👎👎👎

Classic Greek diner. Always good food and service Very covid conscious.

Great service, good food

Great salads, haven’t tried breakfast yet.

Pretty good food. $14 for a cheeseburger is a bit much. I mean well over $30 for lunch for 2 might price some people out.

Heading out east....now to find a diner! Good call...Peconic Bay diner. Socially distant aware, friendly service. Good coffee! (And hot too!) plenty of refills! Even a chance to sit and read the Sunday paper! Stop by!!

Always stop here when in the area, great portions and friendly staff....awesome barley soup!

My family loves this place. Their brioche French toast is to die for. I’ve eaten here several times and anything I order has been well prepared, from a club sandwich with fries to an egg breakfast. My husband says the oatmeal is good. The carrot cake rocks, but it’s the only dessert I’ve tried. I would highly recommend if you looking for a kid friendly, consistent, casual, local eatery.

Always good food and great service

Romanian steak special with dessert EXCELLENT!SERVICE excellent.Prices excellent.. Always take some home can't finish...Cheese danish is perfect! Pleasant atmosphere. Comfortable

Good diner food, reasonable prices.

Good service, food decent

The chicken noodle soup was amazing. Hot open roast beef was so good and they give you so much. I also had a tuna fish wrap and that was so good. The two times my family and I went here we left stuffed. We left with a smile on our face. The people that work there are do nice. You get your food so fast.

Really delicious food and pleasant wait staff.

This was our first time at the Peconic Bay Diner. We had an awesome time. The food there was amazing!I am writing this about 2 weeks after our visit, so I apologize for not remembering our fantastic waitresses name, she deserves the kudos here!She was awesome with her recommendations and service. I ordered the Greek gyro platter with fries...delicious, and the large Greek salad with Spanakopita. The food was plentiful, tasted amazing and was enjoyed greatly!I look forward to our next visit, I'm going to get those pancakes that she recommended!

Food was horrible and tastes sour. Management did not want to know about it waitress very rude and unprofessional. Would not ever recommend this dinner

Amazing food so yummy. Thanks crew. Love you. Jessica Rosen was the best waitress there! If you're going ask for her. Bye.

Excellent service excellent food easy on your pocketbook.

Never have a problem here. Food is good everytime I visit and the waitresses are always sweet

Our hostess and server were nice. Food was mediocre and overpriced. Almost $11 for an order of wings (7) and it didn't even come with celery or carrot sticks

Classic Long Island Diner. We had lunch there in an hour or so we had no trouble getting a seat and service was great. Food is great as well.

The place was cozy and comfortable the wait staff were really nice and the food was good

Food was quick...it was okWe were still eating and the check was brought to us....i guess they assumed we were not going to order anything else. Our check was 37 dollars for 2 breakfast and a side of French fries...a lil overpriced.

Food was excellent and so was the service. This is one of those diners New York is famous for but doesn’t really exist anymore. It’s family run and everyone was great, especially the owner! She was there and waiting tables...and she took care of me and my friend and was wonderful. I’ve never written a review before but I couldn’t not let people know what a great diner this was and....before you leave, try the homemade apple turnovers! She warmed it up for us with vanilla ice cream and whipped cream on the side...delicious! And plenty big enough for the two of us! Awesome place!

This is a very nice diner with generous portions. Quick service and nice atmosphere.

Great diner food. Last of it's kind on the East End

Priced way to high , didn't know who ordered what , bad service , tryed to charge twice as much as was quoted when ordered

Good food for a good price. Servets were friendly and courteous.

Very big menu, good choice of low fat meals, reasonable prices. Staff are very attentive

Cool, old fashioned, kinda diner. Very friendly staff and good food. Everything you'd expect from your all american diner.

Typical Long Island diner which means above average food, portions and prices.

Very good coffee, breakfast cooked how I like it, very reasonable price!

Hit and miss but pretty good this time.waitress was very good

The Chicken Soulvaki was very tasty!Crystal did a fine job and very attentive!. I am from out of state.

Always get the Bacon cheeseburger deluxe and its always great!! A bit on the pricey side but still delicious.